Choosing The Right Saddle

Cutting & reining trainer,
Larry Trocha
"Choosing the Right Saddle For Your Reining or Cutting Horse"
By Larry Trocha
A pro's advice about choosing a saddle that will help your performance.
Listen to this audio clip about saddle design, taken from one of Larry's videos.
![]()
Copyright © 2007-2011 Larry Trocha
I Want To Do Reining or Cutting. What Saddle Do You Recommend?
There are a lot of different brands of saddles available. Darn few of them are designed well for riding and training a performance horse.
For cutting and reining horse events, you definitely need a saddle that’s designed to help you "ride in balance and sit the stop."
First, you want a saddle that was designed and built specifically for reining or cutting. Both of these designs have their individual advantages but remember, just because the manufacturer "calls" it a reining saddle doesn’t mean it was designed "well" for reining.
The reason for this is that most saddle makers are craftsmen, not horsemen. Very few of them know how to ride a reining or cutting horse. It’s kind of like trying to design a winning race car without ever having been in a race.
Anyway, let’s get down to the nitty-gritty and talk about the different elements of a saddle and what to look for.
- Seat: Remember, you want a saddle that will allow you to sit the stop. First of all the seat of the saddle should lay close to the horse’s back. The closer you can get to the horse the better. Anything more than a couple inches above the back is too high.
Also, the lowest part of the seat should be near the "middle" of the seat. This low part is called the "pocket". If the pocket is too far back you’ll be forced against the cantle. Too far forward and you’ll slide up on the swells.
On my best saddles, the "pocket" is a little bit farther back than the middle of the seat. I'd say about 2/3rds of the way back from the front. - Beware of too small a seat. You need enough room to slide forward and back a little. The average size woman usually needs a 16” to 16 ½” seat. The average man, 16” to 17”. Also, I personally like a seat that is built up in front. This gives a more secure ride. However, the pocket should still be near the middle of the seat.
- Horn and swells: This is the main difference between a reining saddle and a cutting saddle. In reining your rein hand needs to be able to move unobstructed. Too high a horn or swells will get in the way. I’d want the horn no higher than 31/2”. And the swells no higher than 8”. I also like the horn to be small in diameter. In a cutting saddle, I like the swells and horn to be a little higher, around 81/2 or 9". And the horn to be tilted a little forward. Actually, here on the west coast, a lot of folks will show their reiners in a cutting saddle.
- Stirrup Leathers: This is one of the most critical parts of the saddle, yet the most overlooked. You want the stirrup leathers hung far forward. Ideally, within a couple of inches right behind the swells.
The reason is simple. To be able to stay balanced on a horse that stops and turns hard, you’ve got to sit down in the saddle. I mean way down. If the stirrup leathers are hung too far back, your feet will be behind your center of gravity and cause you to fall forward.
The result will be a loss of your balance which causes the horse to come out of the stop. Also the stirrup leathers and fenders should be made of fairly thin, flexible leather. For precise leg cues, you don’t want a lot of bulk between your leg and the horse. - Cantle: Don’t buy one of those buckaroo saddles with an 6” high cantle. It’ll hit you in the back when you try to sit a hard stop. Quite a few of the "trail" saddles also have a steep, high cantle. Stay away from them. 31/2 inches high max.
- Rigging: How your saddle is rigged is extremely important. And no compromise on rigging should ever be made when choosing a saddle. The saddle you want should have a Full-Double or 7/8th rigging.
Some horses need a saddle with a 7/8 rigging. But never, ever buy a saddle that is ¾ or center-fire rigged. The saddle will slide too far forward on the horse's back.
Look at the way a horse is built. The narrowest part of his underline is right behind the front legs (girth). This is where the cinch automatically wants to go.
If a saddle with a 3/4 rigging is placed in the correct position on a horse's back, the position of the cinch will be back towards the horse's belly. It will just naturally migrate forward to the horse's girth area, taking the saddle forward with it.
I also prefer the rigging Dee to be either in-skirt or dropped 3 or 4 inches below the swells (called a dropped rigging). This allows for the tree to pull down more evenly on the horse's back. Both will be less bulky and give you closer contact with your horse, too. - Tree: Make sure the tree fits your horse’s back. If it’s too narrow or too wide your horse won’t be comfortable. Double check to be sure there is enough clearance between the horse’s withers and the gullet (a minimum of 1”).
A big problem with a lot of saddle trees, is that the bars don't have enough curve or bevel at the end of the bars to fit the horse's back. If your horse is a little sway-backed and the saddle tree is real straight, your horse is going to get a sore back.
The reverse is also true. If you put a tree that has a lot of curve on a straight-backed horse, he's going to get sore. The bars must match the shape of the horses back or there will be problems.
When in doubt about a saddle, have a knowledgeable trainer take a look at how it fits your horse. His opinion might save you and your horse some grief.
To learn more about choosing the right saddle, watch the two video clips on the right of this page.
Good luck,

Larry Trocha
Teach Your Horse to Stop, Spin, Change Leads and Work Cattle
California cutting and reining trainer, Larry Trocha has created the ultimate horse training videos. In each video, you'll see proven, easy to learn methods that are guaranteed to work. Check them out at www.HorseTrainingVideos.com.Get Larry's Horse Training Tips Insider, Absolutely Free!
Get it here: http://www.horsetrainingvideos.com/clips-signup.htm
Hi Larry. I'm looking to get into cutting and reining and was wondering if you would email me the list of saddle makers that you would reccomend? Thanks!
Hi larry i would also like a list of saddle makers that you would recomend and if they have a website. and while i am taking up your time i would like to thank you for the news letters and the videos, they have helped me and my horse out greatly. The best money i have ever spent on information about horse training.
Hi, Larry!
I love cutting and belong to a jackpot cutting club. As I get older and fatter, I am having a hard time sitting the stop, ducks and dives that makes cutting so much fun. I am very fat, short legged and am having a very confusing time finding a cutting saddle that will help me with my faults. I have seen some very old, fat men sit a saddle like it is a rocking chair, but I am too embarrased to approach them to see the make of the saddle. I know I will need an 18" if not more seat (I worry about hurting the horse's back getting such a long saddle?). It is hard for my short arms to get around my protruding belly to allow me to push on the saddle horn. So, I am thinking very high swells and a extremley slanted horn is something that I want in a saddle. Of course, the leathers are always an issue with me since my short legs don't give me the leverage that long legged people get. I almost feel that saddle bronc leathers are what I need (just kidding)! I know the best thing I can do is lose the weight and stop growing old, but that is easier said than done. So, do you mind e-mailing me the names of saddle makers that make the high swells and very deep pocket, plus very far set ahead leathers so I can continue enjoying cutting in the future. Thank you. Hope
I watched your video on saddles and it was very interesting. Which has made the saddle buy process alot harder. I saw in your comments you would e-mail some saddle makers names. I would love to know of some so I may contact them.
Thank you!
Hi Larry,
I've been viewing your video about the reining saddle. And would like information as to what maker of saddle that you are recommending. Do they have a web site to see there saddles and prices?? Thank You Larry.
Hi Larry, I viewed your video on saddle selection and am looking for a saddle to use for reined cow horse. You mentioned that you knew of a saddle maker. Would you please email his name? Thanks Larry
Hi Larry
We live in South Africa and my daughter is about to start reining – it's very new here and there are almost no saddles available so we'll probably have to import one from the States. Would you mind sending me an email with recommendations on which brands to look at? Many thanks.
Hi Larry. I just viewed your video on reining and cutting saddles. I am just getting into the reined cow horse discipline and need a good saddle. Would you have a recommendation? Thanks, Liz
Larry, thank you for doing this video series. I am a dressage rider who is switching to reining and man am I having a hard time finding a saddle that fits and unlike my trusty dressage saddle, there's no stuffing to help minor issues. The youngsters at the local tack shop don't have any idea what a saddle tree looks like when it's stripped down. I've been looking at Dave Genadek's saddles but I haven't ridden in his reining saddles. Would you be willing to shoot me an email recommending a saddle maker or particular model that meets your standard? Thank you.
Hello Larry –
I am shopping for a reining saddle with semi QH bars (looking to replace one with full bars that slips around too much). It is proving difficult to find. I'm in Northern California, and from the earlier comments it looks like you may have a saddle maker or two you recomment.
I would greatly appreciate your suggestions.
Leave a Comment
45 Comments on Choosing The Right Saddle